<aside> 🗣 Except where indicated, released under a CC-By license, please cite:

Knight, S., Research and Ethics. https://tinyurl.com/TD-res-03

</aside>

<aside> 🤔 The cover image is a network sculpture. Aside from the obvious point - networks are about things, and connections between things, like disciplines! - networks are interesting for other reasons.

Research on networks, and social networks, has been massively interdisciplinary. Social network analysis emerged from sociology. And has been used in biology, communications, geography, psychology, computer science, and many more, with contributions from many fields (including of course mathematics). Its impact has been in:

...each of these (and more) have benefits, but there are also risks and concerns.

Ethics deals with the kinds of principles or knowledge around our moral values, and how we should act.

While it's often negatively framed “don't do X” it's important to remember the positive side of ethics and research. Ethics isn’t just about harm avoidance.

Ethics is about how we act, and in research, our imperative to do research for positive impact in the world


There is lots to continue exploring on these ideas, so this page provides a bit of a whistle stop of some key features.

</aside>

What is ethics?

Ethical approaches are often broken down into three branches:

Rules based approaches these are sometimes called 'deontological' approaches, and they tend to focus on formal rules, compliance, and are expressed in terms of "do not do x"

Outcomes based approaches these are sometimes called consequentialist approaches, and they tend to focus on whether what we do produces positive or negative outcomes, and try to balance these to maximise the positive. They're more likely to be expressed in terms of "we want to minimise harms".

Character based approaches, these are sometimes called virtue approaches or an ethics of care, and they focus on cultivating good reasoning in our decision making, sometimes towards a notion of care or justice

<aside> ⁉️ QUESTION: Which professional codes of conduct, ethical standards, or other expressions of their ethics do you know about?

<aside> 📖 RESOURCE: For research, you need to be aware of the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research

National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (2007) - Updated 2018

You should also be aware of (and closely follow if doing anything with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples):

Ethical research

Code of Ethics

</aside>

</aside>

🗓️A history of research ethics

I’m going to give a few examples of cases where ethical issues have been raised, and how the National Statement tackles them.

But, per AHRECS that these are misleading in some ways, because they imply a kind of ‘event and response’ to ethics development. But that’s inaccurate.

There are a number of difficulties with this ‘schooled by scandal’ history. First, the implicit (and simplistic) assumption of causality between examples of unethical (as seen with the benefit of hindsight) research and the subsequent tightening of regulations, guidelines or standards. Second, the unrepresentative importance accorded to the “scandals” can conceal the fact that most human research at the time was ethically acceptable


  1. Tuskegee (30s-70s) [1973 IRB mandate; failures across justice, respect, beneficence]
  2. WWII atrocities [1947 Nuremburg declaration]
  3. Milgram 1962 [deception/respect + harm/beneficence]
  4. Betrayers of Truth published 1982 [long line of controversies and integrity policies since]
  5. Zimbardo 1971 [beneficence + respect]
  6. Humphreys 1970 [respect, perhaps justice]

As above, in Australia human research ethics is governed by the NHMRC National Statement, and every research institution has a ‘Human Research Ethics Commitee’, which in addition to academics must include: a lawyer, lay people, community pastoral care (e.g. an Aboriginal Elder, a minister).